What You Said: Reader Comments
May 1, 2008

I was happy to see some of you agreed with my shock over Syesha being in the bottom two last week. Keep the comments coming, I LOVE them! Thanks for reading, keep writing.

I do not believe Syesha was in the bottom 3. Now I like everyone in the show (though I liked Ramiele & sort of Carly) .David Cook is a so-so for me.Last week Syesha was the best in the show if it was just my oponion.I thought that Brooke & Jason where going to be in the bottom 2 even though they are some of my favorites.
missjal, 10, WA

I love David cook!The other David is kinda nerdy to me.I loved syesha mercodos performence!
Evabrock

I love David Cook too. And well David Archuletta is my favorite! But Carly should not have gotten out. She was my sister's favorite and I liked her too. Carly and Syesha should not have been the bottom two. As my opinions go the bottom two should have been made up of: Brooke White and Jason Castro. And who should have gotten out? BROOKE WHITE! She forgot the words! And this is way to far into the show to forget your words. Even though David A. did forget his words that was soooosssssooooosssssoooooo long ago. And she had pitch problems. And she also trys to bring the 60's back. HORRIBLE! Carly and Syesha did not deserve the bottom two and Carly definently didn't deserve to go home!
Juliettte07, 9, OH

If you have a comment for me, make sure you send it my way. Don't forget to tune in next week.

Tuned in 24/7,
Idol Fanatic