What You Said: Reader Comments
April 11, 2008

I love reading what you all think about 'American Idol' and what you think of my blog posts. Keep sharing your opinions, I want to know who your favorite is and what you think of the performances.

My favorite contestant is David Archuleta. I know probably EVERY girl in America loves him, but I just can't help it! I thought his performance 'You're The Voice' was amazing. I don't know what Simon was thinking when he said it was 'a theme park performance!' I just loved it! I think David will go very far! I love you David! Rock On!
Julianne

hi, i think american idol is awesome! and david archuleta has dont incredible in almost every performance. though he screwed up a few times, he has an amazing voice and he cud sing anything and blow us all away. i have 2 admitt that david cook is good but im not a huge fan. maybe cuz rock isnt really my style and there r other great ppl in the competition that i perfer. i think syesha is also wonderful although her baby cry is kinda creepy.but i do think kristy lee cook shud go she isnt as talented as the others. bye!
Abby

My favorite perfomance was Brook's I love Achelita though!! I heart idol
Marj

I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA HE IS SOOOOOOO CUTE AND HE IS A REALLY GOOD SINGER I HAVE TWO OF HIS SONGS ON MY IPOD ONE IS A VIDEO
Madison

I was really sad to see Brooke White in the bottom three last week. Even though it wasn't her best performance she is one of the best. My dad says that she won't win because she is to good for American Idol but I think she should. He also says that Carley Smithson won't win just because she has tatoos. Isn't that stupid!!
Mrsdylansprouse, 11, ME

I really like Brooke but I don't really think she has the right stuff to win the whole competition. I agree with justMe1998...David Cook is like Daughtry and personally I think Daughtry should have won. It might be just me but isn't the hour long results show a little to long? I mean all they have to do is say whose going home...They really stretch the results.
camimarielee, 11, WA

David Archuleta is SOOOOOOOOO CUTE AND SOOOOOOOO GOOD AT SINGING and is SOOOOOOOOOOOO CUTE!!!!! He is super duper cute and should win american idol. he is a great performer and if i had a i pod i would buy all his songs and listen to them all day long he is awsome.
sportfan12

I have to say that the best on American Idol right now is David Cook. Don't get me wrong David Achutleta is very cute but David Cook is very talented!! My mom doesn't watch Idol until David Cook sings SILLY HUH??? She jumped up and down when he sang Billy Jean. It was very very exetremley funny. She votes all the time. Well am i the only one who thinks Randy is getting a little more like Simon this Season??????????
Hip_to_da_Hop, 11, UT

I think that tuesday night was very disappointing. Some of the best singers on there were only ok, which doesn't cut it on American Idol. I'm glad that this huge organization, is realizing the importance of helping out! American Idol Gives Back is a huge charity organization that helps so many people.
Belinda

If you have a comment for me, make sure you send it my way. Don't forget to tune in next week.

Tuned in 24/7,
Idol Fanatic